Fat as Hell…

and not going to take it anymore!

Good Enough

Listen to this…

Perfectionism may seem like a desirable trait, but to boost your health, aim for “just enough.” “Trying to do everything right promotes an all-or-nothing attitude,” says Martin Binks, PhD, a psychologist at the Duke Diet and Fitness Center in Durham, NC. So if you can’t do something perfectly (i.e., work out an hour a day), you don’t do anything at all (i.e., watch TV instead).

And this…

A better mindset: Believe that every little bit counts. “It’s small changes that are most effective,” Binks says. So forget perfect!

Gosh. This really hits home for me. Though I would never label myself as a perfectionist, I can definitely remember numerous instances wherein my attitude has fallen into the “all-or-nothing” category. Although it seems silly, I frequently find myself thinking things like, “well, it’s too late to exercise for a full hour, so what’s the point?” or “If I’m not going to walk my full 3 mile route, then why bother walking at all?”

I’m telling you, this kind of stuff is hard to admit, because frankly, it sounds like the rantings of a complete lunatic, but if I’m going to be completely honest then I have to tell you that I also play these kinds of games with food. Let’s say, for example, that on my way to work I inexplicably find myself at Starbucks sucking down an iced venti no whip white mocha (which happens more frequently than I care to admit)… often, later in the day, I will use that slip up as an excuse to NOT make the right choices AGAIN: “Well, I already drank about 500 calories this morning, so I might as well eat this brownie, right?” I fall into the “all-or-nothing” mentality, adopting a “what’s the point?” attitude as though one (albeit big) slip-up has ruined the entire day.

And here’s the thing, that kind of defeatism is not only unhealthy, but it’s also really, really stupid.

And what’s more, I realize it’s just an excuse, an easy way for me to bargain my way out of having to exercise or eat right at all, but man, I don’t think I really realized how much I did that until I read this article in which the authors outline what they call the Good Enough Guide to Healthy Living. In each category they identify the “gold standard,” or the things that we would all do every day in a perfect world… but then they go onto to discuss what they term “good enough” goals *and* the significant health benefits that can result from even making small changes in your life.

The exercise one was a biggie for me, but there’s something to be learned, I feel, from their suggestions in all of the categories.

That said, I think part of my problem lately has been that I started expecting way too much of myself. I had a few kick-ass months, ate right, exercised frequently and took off more weight than I ever thought possible, but it was wrong to expect that kind of performance, and thus those kinds of results, from myself all of the time. Even though I didn’t see it at the time, it’s clear to me now that I set my goals a little too high and when I found myself in a position where I couldn’t achieve them, I just threw my hands up in the air and said “why bother?”

*sigh*

You know, so many of my favorite weight-loss bloggers have been quiet lately, and I have to tell you that I’m worried that they too are adrift in a high calorie, low self-esteem sea. To that end, a long time ago, Krissie wrote a post that I’ve actually quoted several times now. In it she said…

I am a new person most of the time. And that’s good enough. I’m never going to be perfect. But I can be healthy repeatedly, and let that crowd out my mistakes.

I know she gets tired of me quoting her all of the time, but I think there’s a lot of wisdom in those words. Furthermore, I think that if we all cut ourselves a little slack now and then, we’d probably all be far better off.

So… however I go about getting back in the swing of things *this* time, I know one thing for sure. I’m going to really, really try to not allow myself to fall into the trap of “all-or-nothing.” Like Krissie, I too am a new person *most* of the time. And, I bet if you think about it, you are too. None of us are going to be perfect all of the time. But we *can* do the right thing repeatedly. And the thing I’m starting to realize is… that really *is* good enough.

June 15, 2008 - Posted by justoofat | health, losing weight, motivation | , , , , , , , , , | 19 Comments

19 Comments »

  1. What a lovely post! I ran across it this morning I was struggling with my own “well, it IS Sunday, and father’s day, so maybe we could splurge a little this morning and have bacon, pancakes, and fried apples for breakfast” self-defeating nonsence.

    Thank you!

    Comment by sarahemc2 | June 15, 2008

  2. You definitely made me stop and think about the way i look at food and exercise. I too am an all or nothing kind of person. But i’m going to try to think a bit before i do or not do things ;)

    Comment by suzanne | June 15, 2008

  3. later in the day, I will use that slip up as an excuse to NOT make the right choices AGAIN: “Well, I already drank about 500 calories this morning, so I might as well eat this brownie, right?” I fall into the “all-or-nothing” mentality, adopting a “what’s the point?” attitude as though one (albeit big) slip-up has ruined the entire day.
    ***************************************

    This is my life. I’m much better about it now, but YEAH. Great perspective in this post and good for me to keep in mind.

    Comment by pantrypuff | June 15, 2008

  4. Such a fantastic post! One of the biggest factors in my own success has been the shift in focus to being “better” rather than the “best.” Little things add up, and more quickly than you ever dreamed. :)

    Thanks so much for the “good enough” link! I’m off to share it with a friend, now. :)

    Comment by Cammy | June 15, 2008

  5. So many familiar themes.

    Before I started my diet this year, it was very much a case of I’ve already had too many and so one more cookie isn’t gonna make THAT much difference.

    I didn’t think of myself as a perfectionist and then, about 10 years ago, Oprah did a show on it and read out a test to see how perfectionist we are. I did it at the time. I came out the last but one level which meant “you annoy your friends with it”. The next level up was “you need help”!

    So, yes, I am a perfectionist. It’s useful some of the time but otherwise I treat it like a disability in that I have to rein myself in.

    My husband told me about Good Enough some years ago, that it was okay to strive for Good Enough, especially when I was having trouble completing things.

    Now, I choose my activities carefully – otherwise I’ll get drawn in and want to do it completely. My food diary is my latest addition.

    Sorry, this is a long-winded way of saying “I hear ya.”

    (I found a perfectionist test and got 60%)

    Comment by Paola | June 15, 2008

  6. Yep, striving for perfection is setting yourself up for failure.

    Comment by AndrewE | June 15, 2008

  7. Wow, girl. i’d forgotten I’d said that. Maybe I should go back and listen to myself…

    And the iced venti (3-pump) white mocha (WITH whip)? Yeah, I’m finishing one right now. I’ve made the decision that they will be non-existant during the week, but I can splurge on the weekends, if I so desire.

    Thank you so much for the email. You encouraged me and Nathan at once!

    Have a great week!

    Comment by krissie | June 15, 2008

  8. Good post-it goes back to being patient and gentle with ourselves, it just isn’t realistic to demand so much of ourselves all the time. Let’s take it one week, one day one step at a time, gently encouraging ourselves through it all, and also forgiving ourselves for the inevitable times when we will be human. Have a great week,
    K.
    til.i.reach.com

    Comment by K. | June 15, 2008

  9. Interesting thing I noticed while reading this post. I have scrolled down and am reading the comments when I notice you Monthly Progress chart.

    I see 10 lbs lost (hopefully never to be found again) in April, 5.3 lost in March, and so on.

    If your goal is to lose fat/get healthy/etc, you are doing a great job.

    If you can do this and still enjoy the occasional Starbucks sugar bomb delight, GOOD FOR YOU!!!

    Weight loss doesn’t require perfection. It may take a little longer but you are obviously doing great in your own way.

    Comment by DR | June 16, 2008

  10. I have found that to be absolutely true: I get into a certain mind set (I will do 45 minutes on the elliptical trainer today or NOTHING) and then it’s easy to say no to that.

    So I have tried to implement the change you’re suggesting and have found it to be very helpful.

    The other mindset change I have had is how I look at food. I view every meal as an opportunity to start anew. In the past I would tell myself I was on a diet and if I blew it, I would go nuts for the next couple of days. Then I would wait until Monday to start a new diet.

    What I have realized is that sometimes, in the middle of the day, I want three chocolate chip cookies. So I eat them and enjoy them. Then at the next meal, I try to eat right.

    I find there is no guilt in eating those cookies, because I wanted them, I enjoyed them and I am back on the wagon, as they say, at the next meal.

    That one change in thinking has been so helpful to me.

    Comment by cardiogirl | June 16, 2008

  11. Wow, that totally hit the nail on the head. But I’m always so afraid that if I allow myself an inch, I’ll take a mile. It is definately a very difficult balance.

    Comment by Megan | June 16, 2008

  12. This post may well end up on the fridge, some great thoughts to start the day with.

    Comment by Jenny | June 16, 2008

  13. Thank you for this post. It came at a time that I really needed it. Again, thank you. :)

    Comment by Olivia | June 16, 2008

  14. Such a great post and so very true. I am a perfectionist in most every other part of my life and not my body. Kind of ironic, I guess. I confess, I am one of those all or nothing type girls. If I screwed up one day, I would throw the whole week in. I think that’s why I am still around now though is I have reformed my thinking. I don’t really know how I did that but I did. Granted, I am not seeing the losses on the scale, but everyday I continue to try.

    I will probably also save this post….kudos!

    Comment by Bonnie | June 17, 2008

  15. sarahemc2: Sarah, holidays of any stripe are, I find anyway, fraught with traps in which I usually get caught. Good for you for staying strong. Bacon and pancakes are, in my opinion, pretty tough to resist. :)

    suzanne: Thank you for your kind words. Reading that article was an eye opener for me, I’m glad I could pass it on.

    pantrypuff: Good for you, girl! Keep up the good fight!

    cammy: One of the biggest factors in my own success has been the shift in focus to being “better” rather than the “best.” Little things add up, and more quickly than you ever dreamed. :) All I can do is nod, Cammy. You always have such a wise and level headed way of putting things. I think I need to start wearing a bracelet that reads WWCD? What Would Cammy Do? ;)

    Paola: Paola, I took the perfectionist test and got a 67%!!! Ack! *smile* Frankly, the fact that you always strive to do what is right, and always deeply consider the things you share with others are just a couple of the reasons why I find your advice/council so valuable.

    Krissie: Gosh, I like the whole “allowing myself something I really want on the weekend” thing. I’ve been thinking about this concept a lot lately and may decide to do a one day a week splurge kind of thing. I think it’s important not to feel deprived… at least for me, anyway. Otherwise, I end up resenting my healthy choices and that can’t be good.

    K: Very well put! Thank you! :)

    DR: I have trouble keeping up with the statistics of all of this. I need an administrative assistant to help me crunch the numbers. That said, I know I’ve been successful, it’s just the consistency part that’s been tough for me. I think I can let go of perfect if I could just be a bit more consistent.

    cardiogirl: The other mindset change I have had is how I look at food. I view every meal as an opportunity to start anew. In the past I would tell myself I was on a diet and if I blew it, I would go nuts for the next couple of days. Then I would wait until Monday to start a new diet. Wow.. what an incredibly wise way to look at it. New meal = new start. I like it! Good luck to you!

    everyone: I’m humbled by all of your kind words. Knowing that something I said might be helpful to you all is amazing to think about. Thank you so much for being so supportive. I value and depend on each of you so much.

    j

    Comment by justoofat | June 18, 2008

  16. Truer words have never been spoken.

    Comment by LoserIrene | June 18, 2008

  17. Am I certainly glad to have stumbled across your blog, and more specifically this post. I have a terrible problem with perfectionism when it comes to myself, and that dreaded “all or nothing” thinking. I have wasted so much time and energy abusing myself for my shortcomings, when it could have been saved for something more productive. This is good encouragement to keep trying to wear down that cruel, critical voice in my head.

    Thank you for your honesty and sharing!

    Comment by Stella | June 18, 2008

  18. This was a particularly powerful post for me today and I am thankful to you for writing it!

    Comment by mal | June 18, 2008

  19. My therapist has a sign in her office that says, “Perfection is a flawed concept.” It’s amazing how perfectionism can creep into our attitudes without us even knowing it!

    Comment by cmae | June 26, 2008


Leave a comment